Comcast Offers High-Definition (HDTV)?
October 21st, 2008 by
imagery
Wow … rather, I mean … WOW. Comcast’s High Definition programming looks horrible! So bad, I had to write about it. If you are thinking about getting an HDTV, I would strongly recommend you get anything besides Comcast. I mean, I really can’t stress how bad it looked in comparison to DirecTV. If you’re going to pay all that money for an HD DVR, HDTV and the service,why get the worst out there?
Here’s what I noticed …
My friend recently purchased an HDTV from Costco and subscribed to the HD package from Comcast. He was quite excited about it because he had seen my HDTV with DirecTV’s HD service, really liked what he saw and couldn’t wait to watch hockey at his house in HD. But once we got everything set up, we both thought the TV picture quality looked … bad. We flipped through all the Comcast HD channels and they all looked less than HD. It didn’t matter whether it was 720p or 1080i, they all looked blocky, pixelated, and rough … if that makes sense. The Comcast Sports Network (CSN) channels were by far the worse. Fast action scenes seemed to exaggerate the imperfections. At first we thought it might be the TV since it was brand new. We though maybe we had it configured wrong or that it might be defective, but after about an hour of tweaking and Googling on the internet, I had convinced myself it had nothing to do with his TV. Seeing the quality firsthand and after reading this website http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1008271 I was pretty certain it was Comcast.
My friend wasn’t so sure, yet. We were watching the Washington Capitals play the Pittsburgh Penguins on NBC and after the first intermission, we drove over to my house and watched the same game on the same channel, just this time on DirecTV. Sure enough, my DirecTV picture looked a hell of a lot better; literally a night and day difference. After the game, we went back to his house, brought my BluRay player, and again messed around with the settings. The TV looked fabulous with my BluRay player, so we were able to rule out a misconfiguration. But we just couldn’t get it to look right with Comcast. When we paused a show, you could really see how chunky the picture looked. It looked very similar to when you keep zooming in on a digital photograph … it starts to look blocky, or chunky.
Later that week, my friend called Comcast and had a technician come out to his house just to make sure there was nothing wrong with the signal coming into his house and to make sure the HD-DVR was working correctly. The tech said the signal looked great, the DVR was working fine and commented how nice his TV was. I guess they talked a bit and my friend realized he wasn’t going to get better picture no matter what. It was never going to match my DirecTV signal. After the tech left, he called DirecTV and ordered the HD package.
Comcast’s HD quality has got to be the worst I have ever seen. I mean, it’s so bad, I’d say it’s marginally better than standard definition. How they call it High-Definition (HDTV) boggles the mind.
Posted in Ramblings |
No Comments »